Public Watchdogs: Because the Public has a right to know

Public Watchdogs is Member Supported.DONATE NOW!

  • Home
  • About Us
    • Board of Directors
  • Donate
  • News
    • Breaking News
    • Press Releases
    • Media Coverage where Public Watchdogs is Quoted
    • Events
  • Whistleblowers
  • Resources
  • Contact

NRC refuses to fine Holtec for violating Federal nuclear safety laws, underscoring its complete failure to protect the public

May 5, 2019May 7, 2019 Public Watchdogs Breaking News, Media Coverage where Public Watchdogs is Quoted, Uncategorized, Updates
Share on Facebook Share
Share on TwitterTweet
Share on Pinterest Share
Share on LinkedIn Share
Send email Mail

At San Onofre, NRC rejects fine against Holtec for changing design of nuclear waste canisters without permission

Company learned from its mistakes, federal regulator says, after deciding not to impose $36,250 penalty
(Public Watchdogs says the NRC is shirking its responsibility to regulate)

The Holtec Hi-Storm Umax dry storage system for spent fuel at San Onofre Nuclear Generating Station. (Courtesy of Southern California Edison)

This story reproduced under the fair use provision of U.S. copyright law 17 U.S. Code § 107.

Get the original story with slide show here.

By TERI SFORZA | tsforza@scng.com | Orange County Register
PUBLISHED: April 29, 2019 at 2:54 pm | UPDATED: April 30, 2019 at 10:19 am

Holtec International, the company making canisters to contain highly radioactive nuclear waste at San Onofre, has escaped fines related to the surprise redesign of those vessels, which caught officials at Southern California Edison and the Nuclear Regulatory Commission off guard.

Part of the reason: San Onofre’s spent fuel is not so hot.

An investigation revealed that Holtec altered the canister design — adding pins to the canister bottoms to facilitate the flow of cooling gas — without permission from the NRC. Holtec considered the change too minor to require NRC scrutiny; the commission disagreed.

“The failure to establish adequate design control measures and obtain NRC approval prior to modifying multi-purpose canisters with four-inch, stainless steel stand-off pins, was deemed potentially safety significant,” the NRC said in its final decision on the matter, released last week.

“Holtec’s design review process for the change did not adequately consider all potential impacts that could adversely affect the safety-related functions. …. The stand-off pins are essential to the function of the fuel basket to maintain support and ensure that the shims remain in place to allow helium to adequately circulate around the fuel assemblies within the canister.”

But the NRC essentially said no harm, no foul.

The waste loaded into four Holtec canisters with the new, unapproved design at the shuttered San Onofre Nuclear Generating Station had been cooling in spent fuel pools for years, and, thus, is not as hot as what the canisters were designed to withstand. That means that even if pins broke — impeding gas flow inside the canister — it wouldn’t pose a safety problem.

However, if the canisters had been loaded with hotter fuel, the failure of multiple pins “could have compromised the heat transfer characteristics,” increasing temperatures inside the canister beyond allowable limits and potentially damaging insulation material, the NRC said.

Holtec had two violations, the NRC said: failure to establish adequate design control measures of components important to safety, and failure to perform evaluations before making changes.

A base civil penalty of $36,250 was considered and rejected due to Holtec’s “prompt and comprehensive” corrective actions, which included the elimination of the pin design; a “lessons learned assessment;” and revised engineering protocols.

That outraged some critics. “The failure by the NRC to fine Holtec for breaking the law shows that it isn’t serious about protecting the public’s safety,” said Charles Langley, executive director of Public Watchdogs, in a statement.

Joy Russell, Holtec’s senior vice president of business development and communications, said the NRC has confirmed the safety of the canisters with the pin design and that the canisters “would continue to be in a safe condition during the entire licensed period of storage” and “did not result in an actual significant safety concern.”

“The loaded canisters do not and never have posed any risk to public health and safety,” Russell said in a statement. “Holtec accepts the violations and … the NRC has determined that Holtec’s violations resulted in having moderate to low safety significance concern. Holtec remains committed to safety in all we do and will continue to work with the NRC.”

Updated 4.30.2019 with statement from Holtec

Get the slide show here at the Orange County Register or scroll down

Get the original story as it appeared in the Orange County Register here

Get the Public Watchdogs press release.


  •  Slide show images below

 

 

 

Share on Facebook Share
Share on TwitterTweet
Share on Pinterest Share
Share on LinkedIn Share
Send email Mail

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Post navigation

NRC “enforcement decision” represents a miserable failure to regulate.
NRC June 3 2019 Webinar now available at PublicWatchdogs.org
  • FACEBOOK

  • TWITTER

Watch Our YouTube Channel

Updates

Why nuclear energy is insane (and why regulators from four nuclear nations have denounced it as an energy source)

May 12, 2022 10:13 am | By Public Watchdogs

Former Chair of  U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission rejects nuclear energy as “not safe” and “not smart” Dateline May 12, 2022 —  E, the Environmental Magazine, has published a compelling article by journalist Sara Mosko titled the Insanity of Expanding Nuclear Energy.  The story explains how four of the world’s top nuclear regulators have issued a joint statement rejecting nuclear energy as a clean, green solution to... Read more →

Workers urge Holtec International to “Stop hiring Homer Simpson”

April 6, 2022 11:55 am | By Public Watchdogs

Trained workers at the Pilgrim nuclear power plant in Massachusetts are claiming  that skilled nuclear technicians are being replaced by unqualified “Homer Simpsons” as a way of cutting labor costs for the plant’s new owner, Holtec International. Holtec’s legal record includes criminal activities such as bribery and outright lying to elected officials, so it is no surprise that the company has serious management problems that have... Read more →

Keep In Touch

Stay in Touch

Enter your email below to be added to our mailing list.

Sending

Categories

Recent Comments

  • D. Rice on Holtec’s corporate shell game, and why it is unfit to handle nuclear waste at Indian Point
  • Public Watchdogs on U.S. Supreme Court kicks nuclear cans down the road to our children
  • Bethann Chambers on U.S. Supreme Court kicks nuclear cans down the road to our children
  • Public Watchdogs on That metallic taste? It’s possible you’ve been irradiated. 
  • RadMan on That metallic taste? It’s possible you’ve been irradiated. 

SIGN THIS PETITION

Petition Form
Note: By signing, you agree to receive email messages from publicwatchdogs.org. You may unsubscribe at any time. If you give us your phone number, we may send you text alerts.
Sending
2021 Public Watchdogs · Developed by That Marketing Geek